Work and leadership Draft, not on the live site
When the Favourites Fall
· 2 min read
Have you ever got that feeling that the presenter up on stage doesn’t really believe what they are saying? They don’t own the message and your sixth sense tells you that they are just delivering the ‘party line’ which has been scripted for them. They appear inauthentic and as they continue a sense of unease spreads through the crowd. You hope the end is near as the awkwardness settles in.
Often these presenters are those whose impressive career acceleration looks almost unbelievable. Perhaps they are an expert in something that is niche or revered, and up to this point, they’ve delivered exceptionally and are extremely well respected. They have untarnished reputations and have had that highly sought after sponsorship by one or many in senior management along the way. And crucially, it is these sponsors who have helped them polish off any reputational blemishes they may have suffered from mistakes or misjudgements along the way, keeping them shiney and untarnished.
Then these individuals step up in front of a crowd without protection. Without the sponsorship protection, they are exposed to real-time judgement from the crowd, which sticks to them like tar. It’s heavy and dark and feels like it may never be removable, and stains them right in front of you.
Suddenly from a great height, the pedestal they have been put on wobbles beneath them, and they find themselves in unfamiliar territory. In a matter of minutes, they are no longer the super star or the golden child, their career acceleration halted.
I have always been drawn to the ‘underdog’, those who are trailing, falling behind, or losing in a race. I’ve not pinpointed why, but it strongly influences my behaviour. At school I was drawn to the smaller ‘nerdy’ groups and the ‘uncool’ kids with whom I felt a sense of kinship with. I never belonged with them or as part of their group, but I was never rejected by them either.
At sporting events, I would shout extra loud for the person coming in last in the race. I could never pick a club or team to support, instead waiting to see who would struggle in competition and wait to see who would be doing it tough.
In supporting the underdogs, I would feel comfortable, at home, in my place.
It was the same with these new self-titled ‘leaders’ on stage. Even though I never felt comfortable with the ‘favourites’ of senior leadership and the unleveling it created, I would still find myself supporting them when they struggled. I would smile at them from my place in the crowd, nodding my head in agreement, sitting forward in my chair, engaged in my posture. Signalling to them that I had their back.
But was I advocating for ‘the favourite’ who already had so much? Or was I supporting the underdog?
Could they be one and the same?
Did this sound like your life? Tell us.