Work and leadership · The Evaporating Ambition Story Draft, not on the live site
The Bonus Gamble
· 2 min read
The idea of getting a ‘bonus’ as part of your earnings has always been so alluring. That someone would pay you each month a salary, but then throw in the possibility of an undisclosed sum of money on top of that is exciting. Like buying a ‘scratchy’ at a shop when I was a kid. Those little cards with the silver foil covering the possibility of a prize or even a big win. You would use your nail to scratch the foil off, revealing if you won or not, the excitement short lived but yet so exciting. Even knowing your odds of winning were almost zero, you would go back for more.
Most years of my career I have received a cash bonus, some small and others bigger than expected. Regardless of the size of my bonus in the years before, I would push myself to deliver more and perform better the following year. The clear motivator being that it would improve my chances of receiving a bigger bonus, but for me it was more than that. It was a measure of how much I was valued by the organisation.
But when I reached more senior levels in the corporate world, what I came to understand was that your salary stopped growing, and it was only your bonus which could increase how much you earned year on year. So with more at stake, the more pressure I put on to myself to perform, and the more of how much I could be valued was also on the line. They make the stakes higher, expecting your performance to continue to improve alongside your expanding responsibilities and deliveries.
But each year the messaging you receive about your bonus doesn’t quite work like that, which is eventually is the same messaging you are asked to give employees when revealing their bonus. The messaging is usually something like this. The size of your bonus is firstly about the organisations performance, then next is your divisions performance, then after that your teams performance. Only then does your individual performance factor in. But then comes the contradiction. None of that performance really matters, because unless you are directly responsible for making money for the company, like in sales, then your bonus’ don’t increase nor decrease with the changing performance of the organisation. Instead, they keep bonus’ smaller and pretty much the same each year.
So what actually is a bonus? Is the organisation setting up the gamble? Or are they themselves gambling that the lure of a bonus will extract continued and improved performance from employees each year, regardless of what employees actually get paid as a bonus? It looks like I have been lured into the gamble. Even knowing the odds are stacked against me, I still pushed myself to perform year after year, bonus after bonus.
Even when scratching off foil has never revealed a win.
Did this sound like your life? Tell us.